In 2019, Taylor Swift couldn’t buy her own music.
Big Machine, the label that owned the master recordings of her first six albums, had been acquired by Scooter Braun’s Ithaca Holdings. Swift said publicly that the offer she’d been given was a chance to “earn” her old albums back, one for each new album she signed up to make.
In 2020 the masters were sold on again, to the investment firm Shamrock Capital.
By any normal reckoning, she had no leverage. They owned the asset. She wanted it. End of story.
So she stopped trying to win that negotiation and started changing it.
Swift re-recorded the albums. Fearless (Taylor’s Version) came out in 2021, then Red, then Speak Now and 1989 in 2023. Her fans followed her to the new versions.
In May 2025 she announced she’d bought back the original masters.
Think about what she did. She didn’t argue harder. She didn’t find a cleverer way to ask. She lowered the value of what the other side was holding by creating a substitute for it.
We tend to think of leverage as something you have or you don’t. It’s more useful to think of it as something you build.
And the most reliable way to build it isn’t to weaken the other side. It’s to improve your own alternative until their asset matters less to you.
But there’s a problem with holding this up as a model. Most of us aren’t Taylor Swift. Very few people have a fanbase that will happily buy the same album twice. It’s fair to ask whether this is a lesson at all, or just a story about extraordinary circumstances.
I think the principle scales down better than it looks. The second quote from another supplier. The job offer you get before asking for a raise. The skill that means you’re not dependent on one employer. None of these are dramatic. All of them change what the person across the table is holding.
Building leverage when you start with none is one of the ideas I explore in my book, Marta Skarbek’s This is Negotiation.
If you couldn’t win the negotiation you’re in, what would it take to make it matter less?
Marta Skarbek’s This is Negotiation: https://www.amazon.com/Marta-Skarbeks-This-Negotiation-negotiator/dp/B0D7VXFV7S
#Negotiation, #TaylorSwift, #Leverage, #MusicIndustry, #Ownership, #Strategy, #Creators, #BusinessLessons, #Entrepreneurship, #MartaSkarbek
Want more like this?
Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.