An election can produce a clear result and still fail to produce a workable government. What does that tell us about the way we measure democratic success?
France offered a striking example in 2024. President Emmanuel Macron called snap parliamentary elections after the European Parliament vote. The result left the National Assembly divided into competing blocs, none with an outright majority. The political uncertainty continued as parties struggled to agree on a governing arrangement.
A political analysis published in the *European Journal of Political Research Political Data Yearbook* described 2024 as a year of turmoil and gridlock. It noted that the election produced no clear winner, with each electoral bloc claiming success, while no bloc could form a government with a secure path to survival.
This is not an argument that elections are pointless. The French vote gave citizens a chance to express their preferences, and the resulting parliament reflected a divided electorate. That is information a democracy needs.
But an election is very good at measuring competing political preferences at one moment in time. It is not necessarily designed to help people with those different preferences work through a problem together.
Imagine asking a room of 100 people to choose between three proposals. The vote might reveal that the room is split almost evenly. The winning proposal could have the support of only a minority. The exercise tells you which option came first; it doesn’t tell you whether the participants could negotiate a better option if they had time, evidence and a reason to listen to one another.
That is the distinction between electoral competition and deliberation.
A citizens’ assembly approaches the problem differently. A representative group is selected by lot and given time to examine an issue. Members hear different perspectives, question experts and consider the consequences of possible choices. They are not trying to defeat an opponent or win the next campaign. Their task is to reach considered recommendations.
Of course, deliberation cannot magically erase deep political disagreement. Nor can a small group claim to speak for every citizen without a carefully designed process and a clear mandate. And the public must be able to see what the assembly did and how its recommendations are handled.
Yet France’s experience invites a useful question. We often judge an election by whether it produces a winner. Should we also judge a democracy by whether its institutions can turn disagreement into decisions?
This is one of the central questions behind *The Answer*, Kizzi Nkwocha’s examination of sortition as an alternative way of selecting decision-makers.
A divided parliament may accurately represent a divided country. But what should happen next?
Is the purpose of democracy to reflect disagreement as faithfully as possible, or should it also be designed to help citizens move beyond it?
Book: https://www.amazon.com/Answer-Sortition-Rebuild-Broken-Politics/dp/B0G6FRDMJ1/
#France, #Democracy, #PoliticalDeadlock, #Sortition, #CitizensAssemblies, #PoliticalReform, #Parliament, #DeliberativeDemocracy, #Governance, #TheAnswer
Want more like this?
Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.