Imagine receiving a letter telling you that you have been selected to help examine a national issue and make recommendations to parliament. You aren’t a politician. You haven’t joined a party. You didn’t win an election. Your name was drawn at random.
Would you take the invitation seriously?
Belgium has taken a step towards making this kind of participation part of its parliamentary process. In February 2024, its Senate adopted legislation enabling mixed deliberative committees. Under the framework described by the OECD, such a committee can bring together 15 parliamentarians and 45 randomly selected citizens to deliberate and make recommendations to the parliamentary chamber.
The detail matters. This is not simply a public meeting where people make speeches and go home. It creates a structured opportunity for citizens and elected representatives to examine an issue together.
There is something unusual about that arrangement. Parliamentarians bring political experience, institutional knowledge and an understanding of how legislation moves through the system. Citizens bring something else: the perspectives of people who live with the consequences of public decisions but do not spend their working lives trying to win political office.
Neither group has a monopoly on wisdom.
A mixed committee also challenges the idea that expertise and democratic legitimacy must come from the same place. A citizen may not know how to draft legislation, but that doesn’t mean they cannot identify an unfair outcome, question an assumption or recognise a practical problem that has escaped professional attention.
Now imagine applying the principle more widely. A group considering housing could include renters, homeowners, builders, local officials and people who have struggled to find somewhere to live. A group examining education could hear from parents, teachers, students and employers. The point would not be to assemble a collection of lobbyists. It would be to create a balanced group capable of learning and deliberating.
There are serious design questions. Who chooses the subject? How are citizens selected? Are they paid and supported so that people with caring responsibilities or low incomes can participate? Who decides which experts are heard? And what prevents parliament from treating the final report as optional reading?
Those questions are not reasons to dismiss the model. They are the questions any serious democratic reform has to answer.
Belgium’s approach is a reminder that sortition does not have to mean abolishing elected parliaments overnight. It can also mean changing who gets a seat at the table, and when.
The broader case for replacing electoral selection with sortition is explored in *The Answer*, Kizzi Nkwocha’s book on democratic reform.
Would you be comfortable with randomly selected citizens helping to shape laws alongside elected politicians, or should law-making remain exclusively in the hands of people chosen at the ballot box?
Book: https://www.amazon.com/Answer-Sortition-Rebuild-Broken-Politics/dp/B0G6FRDMJ1/
#Belgium, #Sortition, #CitizensAssemblies, #Democracy, #PoliticalReform, #Parliament, #PublicParticipation, #Governance, #DeliberativeDemocracy, #TheAnswer
Want more like this?
Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.